Find Your Perfect Natural Lipstick
A complete guide with color swatches and shade descriptions
Updated on April 9, 2020 Written by: 100% PURE®A beauty lover can never have too many lipsticks... right? Don’t worry, we get it! Welcome to a safe space for indulging, obsessing, and learning about every non-toxic natural lipstick formula from 100% PURE. If you’re just dipping your toes into natural beauty, boy have we got some eye candy in store for you!
Choosing the perfect lipstick can be intimidating, so we’ve simplified the process. In this natural lipstick guide we’ll guide you through finishes, shade descriptions, and lipstick swatches. Get ready to meet your one true (lipstick) love!
What Lipstick Finish Should I Get?
Color might be the first thing you notice in any lipstick. But the second most important factor? The finish: gloss, satin, matter, and so forth.
We offer so many varieties of finishes that we’re starting this guide with a lipstick finish refresher course. It’s important to consider what types of finishes will work for your look, or even your personal style. We’ll help you find exactly what you’re looking for in a natural lipstick – minus the missteps.
Types of Lipstick Finishes
Matte and gloss and satin, oh my!
Have you ever stood in your local paint department, obsessively comparing eggshell to semi-matte paint chips? Well, choosing your lipstick is just like choosing your wall paint finish. Lipstick finish matters, and can drastically change the vibe of any shade or makeup look.
We’re comparing common lipstick finishes, to make it easier for you to decide which one is right for you. Explore high impact lipstick finishes to low-key pouts below!
Newsletter Subscribe
for more blog updates and exclusive discounts
Thanks for subscribing!
Check your email for a confirmation message.
Oops! something went wrong.HIGH GLOSS
To sum up this high gloss lipstick finish, think vintage candy red convertible. It’s here, it’s sexy, and it demands to be seen. High gloss shine is extra in a big way – just ask our super juicy Fruit Pigmented® Lip Gloss. This unforgettable finish is perfect for making your pout the center of attention, while the rest of your makeup takes a backseat.
SATIN
Try: Fruit Pigmented Pomegranate Oil Anti Aging Lipstick: Poppy
Satin finish gives off that perfect middle ground shine, and can vary from shade to shade. The majority of satin finish natural lipsticks are highly pigmented and opaque. They serve a smooth feeling (and lustrous look) on your lips.
MATTE
Try: Cocoa Butter Semi-Matte Lipstick: Sonora
Every makeup artist has at least a few matte lipsticks in regular rotation. Matte lipsticks are the complete opposite of gloss or shine. The flat and almost powdery finish has a way of making even the most daring shades wearable; that means matte lipsticks tend to provide more universally flattering hues.
TINT
Try: Fruit Pigmented Lip & Cheek Tint: Cranberry Glow
Meet your multitasking hero that colors cheeks and lips! It’s a blendable and buildable formula, with a creamy butter-balm texture. The easy push-pop tube makes our lip tint super travel-friendly for adding color on-the-go.
Before You Choose Your Perfect Lipstick Shade...
To be sure you’re picking the most flattering shade for you, start by identifying your skin tone. No matter if your skin is fair, medium, or deep, everyone has a tone to their skin. That tone is the most important factor to consider when searching for your perfect shade of natural lipstick.
Check out the basic skin tone breakdown below. It will help you navigate the guide ahead:
COOL SKIN TONES: Pink, Blue undertones
WARM SKIN TONES: Yellow, Golden undertones
OLIVE SKIN TONES: Mix of Green, Red, and Yellow undertones
Your Guide to EVERY Natural Lipstick
Our fruit pigmented® natural lipsticks get their spectacular color from fruits like pomegranates, raspberries, and plums. When you look below at our stunning lipstick swatches, you’ll wonder why you ever considered using a lipstick colored with crushed bugs!
These natural lipsticks are packed with antioxidants, vitamins, and deeply moisturizing butters for a multitasking lip treatment. It’s a 2-for-1: beauty and brains in a lipstick tube.
Cocoa Butter Matte Lipstick
Finish: Matte
Vegan: Yes
Gluten Free: Yes
Cruelty Free: Yes
Shade Range: 24
We’ve formulated almost twenty on-trend matte lip colors so you don’t need to compromise beauty for your health.
“Most matte lipsticks contain tons of toxic chemicals and are full of heavy metals. Being that 100% PURE lipsticks are colored from berries, the heavy metals and toxins are not a concern," says founder Susie Wang.
Forget what you know about conventional matte lipsticks that leave your lips dry, cakey, and flakey. We’ve formulated our natural lipsticks in a velvety base of cocoa and shea butters to moisturize your pout. Superfine, ultra soft rice powder is the key ingredient in achieving that perfect matte finish.
This collection of matte colors was even voted Best Lipstick by Dirty Thinkers’ Choice Awards in 2018, put on by the scrupulous clean beauty verifier Think Dirty.
PRO TIP: Expand your Cocoa Butter Semi-Matte Lipsticks shade range but mixing two or three lipsticks together. Create a custom shade that’s truly unique to you!
Shade Description: Neutral berry red with fuschia undertone
Best Skin Tone: warm, cool, or olive
Pomegranate Oil Anti Aging Lipstick
Finish: Satin-Gloss
Vegan: Yes
Gluten Free: Yes
Cruelty Free: Yes
Shade Range: 16
Pomegranate is one of our favorite fruits for oh-so-many reasons. It’s chock-full of potent pink pigment, along with vitamin C and anti-aging antioxidants. This formula was also voted Best Natural Lipstick for the 2019 Elite Magazine Beauty Awards!
We’ve formulated our Pomegranate Oil Anti Aging Lipsticks with super moisturizing pomegranate seed oil in a creamy base of shea butter. This super concentrated anti-aging formula will keep your lips super soft all day, while delivering long lasting color. It’s basically a lip treatment that happens to be in your perfect lipstick shade.
Lip Glaze
Finish: Semi-Opaque Gloss
Vegan: Yes
Gluten Free: Yes
Cruelty Free: Yes
Shade Range: 17
Have you been looking for that perfect blend of a natural lipstick and lip balm? Look no further our cruelty-free Lip Glaze collection was created to give you a moisturizing, sheer wash of color for your lips.
Treat your lips to deep hydration with skin softening avocado butter and cocoa butter, infused with concentrated fruit antioxidants. Lip Glazes are perfect for on-the-go makeup application; quickly swipe onto lips and you’re ready to get back to it! Keep one in your pocket, gym bag, or office drawer; the semi-sheer coverage is forgiving enough to swipe on like a lip balm.
Lip Caramel
Finish: High Gloss
Vegan: Yes
Gluten Free: Yes
Cruelty Free: Yes
Shade Range: 7
We created the Lip Caramel Collection for all beauty lovers who want intense, highly-pigmented liquid lipsticks. Intense, saturated color from fruit and achiote seeds is what infuses this lightweight liquid lip formula. Our innovative Lip Caramels combine the smooth texture of gloss with the high performance effects of a natural lipstick. Each lip caramel’s subtly sweet scent of vanilla and caramel will leave you reminiscing over delectably sweet treats!
PRO TIP:Apply the Lip Caramel directly to lips, outlining first for a clean line. Leave as is for a high gloss finish, or blot gently with a tissue for a stained look.
Fruit Pigmented® Lip Gloss
Finish: High Gloss
Vegan: Yes
Gluten Free: Yes
Cruelty Free: Yes
Shade Range: 5
So this is a natural lipstick guide – but can’t we toss in our juiciest, glossiest lip products, too? Not only can these lip glosses steal the show all on their own, they can also be layered over any shade or finish for an extra pop of glossy color. The best part about these shades is that they’re sheer, meaning they will complement virtually any skin tone.
This sheer formula features restorative antioxidant vitamin E, to soften and protect the lips from environmental damage. Subtle pigment from real fruits like bilberry, blackberry, and pomegranate mingle with anti-aging red wine resveratrol for double-duty color and nourishment.
PRO TIP:Want to layer a lip gloss over your favorite lipstick shade? Apply lipstick to clean, dry lips. For best results, wait until your base shade is fully set before gliding on your lip gloss.
If you can’t get enough lipstick eye candy, check out our guide to the best lipstick for every occasion! Answer your questions on lipstick ingredients in our natural vs. synthetic lipstick exposé.
If you’re really serious about making the switch to natural makeup, check out our other comprehensive guide, How to Choose the Best Natural Foundation. We’re all about safe, beautiful, and natural ingredients for the win!
SHOP THE STORY